How to choose
Written by OnlineOrNot. This is a comparison of published capabilities, not a reliability benchmark. Unverified claims are not treated as missing features. Documented examples, not hands-on benchmark results.
Choose New Relic when
You want synthetic checks connected to your existing New Relic telemetry and application investigation.
A viewer is not a synthetic-monitor operator
Three engineers must manage synthetic checks, while finance only needs a shared dashboard.
Price the engineers as full-platform users and use free basic access where it meets a viewer’s needs. New Relic combines synthetic results with observability data; a public dashboard does not by itself provide a customer incident page with subscriptions.
Example documentationLimitations and requirements to check
- Confirm current plan allowances, intervals, regions, team access, alert destinations and status-page requirements at the source before buying.
Migration boundaries for New Relic
- Keep application errors, traces, infrastructure telemetry and associated investigations in this product if you still need them; OnlineOrNot does not replace them.
Choose OnlineOrNot when
You want focused managed uptime, API checks, standalone Playwright scripts, heartbeats and hosted status pages without adopting a full observability platform.
A success page is not a completed checkout
Your storefront still responds with HTTP 200, but submitting an order no longer reaches the confirmation screen.
Use a standalone Playwright journey to sign in, submit a test order and assert the confirmation. An HTTP availability check alone does not exercise those steps. Keep native on-call scheduling or APM in a separate product if you need them.
Example documentationCurrent limitations
- Hobby is free and includes 3 uptime monitors at 3-minute intervals, 1,000 browser runs per month, 2 team members and 100 email status-page subscribers. SMS, webhooks and on-call integrations are not included on Hobby.
- Pro HTTP checks support 30-second scheduling, not a guaranteed 30-second alert. Browser frequency, run duration and region count affect usage.
- Alerts on invalid or expired certificates when SSL verification is enabled. No advance-expiry reminders
- Standalone browser scripts do not replace a full Playwright project, arbitrary dependencies, private runners, application tracing or native on-call scheduling.
- Enterprise reliability guarantees depend on your contract. No zero-false-positive or faster-than-competitors guarantee is offered.
Comparable workload costs
20 uptime monitors, three active operators and one public status page. Usage-priced HTTP estimates assume one request per monitor every minute for 30 days in one location: 864,000 HTTP executions. The browser workload adds two journeys every five minutes for 30 days in one region: 17,280 executions. More regions, retries, longer runs or retained products can add cost. HTTP intervals vary by plan; these are not equal-performance claims.
Monthly prices where published, before tax; currencies are not converted. Annual commitments, usage estimates, incomplete packages and subtotals are labelled. Browser totals include the base workload unless explicitly marked incomplete. Check current quotes before purchasing.
| Product | Uptime workload | With browser journeys (total) |
|---|---|---|
| OnlineOrNot | USD $25/month Pro $15 + one 25-monitor pack $10; unlimited users and public page included | USD $85/month Pro $15 + one 25-monitor pack $10; unlimited users and public page included; 15 packs × $4 = $60 |
| New Relic | USD $208/month for monitoring only Standard first full-platform user $10 + 2 additional full-platform users × $99; 3 users; public status page separate Three full-platform operators are assumed; free basic users have different access. Simple ping checks are excluded from the synthetic execution quota. A public incident status page is separate; data ingest above the included allowance and enabled add-ons cost extra. | USD $244.40/month for monitoring only Standard first full-platform user $10 + 2 additional full-platform users × $99; 3 users; public status page separate; 7,280 billable browser executions × $0.005 per 1 Three full-platform operators are assumed; free basic users have different access. Simple ping checks are excluded from the synthetic execution quota. A public incident status page is separate; data ingest above the included allowance and enabled add-ons cost extra. |
OnlineOrNot: pricing assumptions
- Monthly USD, before tax. One public page and unlimited Pro members are included; additional pages, private-page features, runs and monitor packs cost extra.
New Relic: pricing assumptions
- The estimate uses Standard with three full-platform operators and stays within the included data-ingest allowance. The browser workload consumes the non-ping synthetic quota and adds usage at the published execution rate. Public status-page costs, other telemetry and optional compute are not included.
Migration boundaries
- Recreate supported checks, credentials, regions, assertions and alert routing. Test a controlled failure and recovery in parallel before cancelling your current service.
- Historical incidents, response-time data, SLA reports, integrations, status-page domains and subscriber lists do not automatically transfer. Export an archive and plan each cutover.
- Keep unsupported capabilities in the existing product. Agree assisted-migration scope and timing; do not send secrets by email.
Sources and review status
OnlineOrNot — selected facts checked 2026-11-04
Reviewed evidence
The new-customer Pro package includes 35 monitors; larger monitor and browser allowances use add-ons.
https://onlineornot.com/pricing35 monitors
Observed 2026-11-04
New Relic — selected facts checked 2026-11-04
Reviewed evidence
The estimate assumes three full-platform operators, not three free basic viewers.
https://newrelic.com/pricing$99/additional user
Observed 2026-11-04
Standard includes 10,000 non-ping synthetic checks per month; simple ping checks are excluded.
https://docs.newrelic.com/docs/synthetics/synthetic-monitoring/getting-started/monitor-limits/Standard: 10K per month
Observed 2026-11-04
Scheduled jobs can alert on custom event results and missing signals.
https://docs.newrelic.com/docs/alerts/create-alert/examples/monitor-scheduled-jobs/loss of signal
Observed 2026-11-04
Additional non-ping synthetic checks use a published per-execution rate.
https://newrelic.com/pricingAdditional synthetics checks beyond the amount included in your edition are available at $0.005 per check.
Observed 2026-11-04
Help us correct this comparison
We welcome corrections from readers and competitors. Email max@onlineornot.com with the page, claim and a primary source. A person reviews corrections before publication.
What to evaluate before switching
A viewer is not a synthetic-monitor operator
Price the engineers as full-platform users and use free basic access where it meets a viewer’s needs. New Relic combines synthetic results with observability data; a public dashboard does not by itself provide a customer incident page with subscriptions.
Price the same workload
Compare monitor count, intervals, regions, browser runs, three team members and one public status page. Include add-ons and any tools you must retain.
Test the replacement before cancelling
Recreate supported checks and validate failures, recoveries and alert delivery in parallel. Historical records and unsupported capabilities do not automatically move.
Compare New Relic Synthetics vs OnlineOrNot
| Feature | New Relic | OnlineOrNot |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing | Per-GB ingestion + seats + checks | From $25/month for 35 monitors; additional packs of 25 for $10/month |
| Check frequency | Variable by tier | 30 seconds Pro; 3 minutes Hobby |
| Setup complexity | Agent install, extensive config | Managed service; setup depends on check requirements |
| Failure confirmation | Configurable | Failures confirmed before alerting |
| Cron job monitoring | Scheduled-job alerts using custom events, thresholds and loss of signal | Yes |
| Status pages | Public dashboards are available; a customer incident status page is a separate requirement | One public page on Pro; additional pages cost extra |
| Bill predictability | Depends on configuration and support agreement | Plan and selected add-ons; usage and configuration affect cost |
| Time to value | Depends on configuration and support agreement | Minutes |
| Support | Tiered by plan | Email the founder; response time is not guaranteed |
The migration process
1. Sign up free
Create your account with a 14-day trial. No credit card required.
2. Add your critical monitors
Start with your most important endpoints—core URLs, key APIs, any cron jobs that can't fail silently.
3. Run in parallel
Run OnlineOrNot alongside your current tool during the trial. Compare check results, alert timing, and workflows.
4. Migrate fully
Recreate and validate supported checks, integrations and status-page settings. Email the founder for migration help; agree scope and timing before relying on it.
5. Cancel the old tool
After you validate coverage and alert delivery, turn off duplicate monitors in your previous tool.
What is New Relic?
You want synthetic checks connected to your existing New Relic telemetry and application investigation.
What is OnlineOrNot?
OnlineOrNot monitors websites, APIs, browser flows and scheduled jobs. Pro HTTP checks can run every 30 seconds; Hobby HTTP checks run every 3 minutes.
Failures are confirmed before alerting to help reduce false alerts. Configure regions and alert destinations for each check.
Pro includes one public status page. Additional pages and private-page features cost extra. Hobby has limited status-page features.
How OnlineOrNot improves reliability
Faster detection without the noise
Pro HTTP checks support 30-second intervals. Failure confirmation helps reduce false alerts; it does not guarantee zero false positives.
Everything in one place
Monitor websites, APIs, cron jobs, and heartbeats from one dashboard. Alerts on invalid or expired certificates when SSL verification is enabled. No advance-expiry reminders No need to stitch together multiple tools.
Status pages included
Pro includes one public status page with a custom domain. Additional pages and private-page features cost extra.
Unlimited team members, real support
Add your whole team on Pro or Enterprise. When you need help, email the founder directly instead of going through tiered support.
Need to pitch OnlineOrNot to your bosses?
Here are the key points to help you get stakeholder buy-in:
"We can confirm failures before alerting"
Pro HTTP checks support 30-second intervals. Alert timing also depends on timeouts, confirmation and delivery.
"We're going to save money"
Compare the complete setup: uptime checks, browser runs, status pages, integrations, and team access.
"We get everything in one tool"
Uptime, API monitoring, cron jobs, heartbeats, and status pages. One subscription, one dashboard.
"We can contact the founder"
Email the founder for support. Response times depend on the request and any agreed support terms.